Corporate Art in Insolvency: Ownership Must Be Proven Before It Can Be Sold

Art law is usually discussed in the context of collectors, museums and auction houses. Yet it reaches into boardrooms more often than one might think. A recent judgment of the Bombay High Court shows how quickly corporate law, insolvency and the art market collide – and invites a comparison with the German approach.

What a Bombay High Court ruling and a Düsseldorf judgment mean for companies that own art:

The Mumbai case: 44 paintings, five proven

On 21 October 2026, Justice Somasekhar Sundaresan of the Bombay High Court decided a long-running dispute in the liquidation of Mafatlal Dyes and Chemicals Ltd (Yasmin Mohamed Yunus Valibhoy v. Mafatlal Dyes and Chemicals Ltd, 2026 LLBiz HC(BOM) 590). The company had been ordered to be wound up in 2010.

In January 2014, the Mumbai Crime Branch seized 44 paintings by renowned Indian artists in the course of investigations arising from disputes within the Mafatlal promoter family. The works have since been kept at the Sir J.J. School of Art, in the deemed possession of the Company Court.

Three camps laid claim to them:

  • The Official Liquidator asserted that five identified paintings belonged to the company and sought permission to sell them for the creditors.
  • Sheetal Mafatlal claimed all 44 works, relying on consent terms signed by family members in 2012.
  • Gayatri Jhaveri, another family member, claimed the remaining 39.

The court sided with the liquidator on the five works – among them two paintings by M.F. Husain and works by F.N. Souza, Biren De and Jogen Chowdhury. What carried the day was a consistent chain of documents: the company’s asset register, purchase vouchers and the seizure records, corroborated by the police investigation and by confirmation from an art foundation.

The family settlement, by contrast, was of no help. The family members could not give away what they had never proven to own; an agreement among them could not bind the liquidator. The court also drew an adverse inference from the fact that Sheetal Mafatlal, despite repeated opportunities over many years, declined to give evidence.

One nuance matters for an accurate reading: the court expressly confined its findings to the five works the liquidator wished to sell. The fate of the other 39 paintings remains open.

How the court ordered the sale

The court observed that the conventional auctions used in liquidations for land, machinery and other industrial assets are unsuited to works of art. Price discovery in the art market depends on specialist knowledge, the right audience and the right setting.

Instead of leaving the sale to the standard procedure, the court therefore appointed an art expert, Sonal Singh Naharwar, to oversee the sale of the five paintings, assisted by counsel.

The judgment also shows a notable concern for the physical condition of the works. After more than a decade in storage, preserving the remaining collection had itself become an issue for the court. It directed the two family claimants to deposit ₹15 lakh each with the Official Liquidator to fund the preservation of the remaining artwork.

The lesson is uncomfortable but simple: Every year of dispute is a year of humidity, temperature swings and handling – and of value quietly draining away from the estate.

The German perspective: Immendorff’s 70 monkeys

German courts know the same problem. A well-known example is the judgment of the Düsseldorf Regional Court (Landgericht Düsseldorf) of 8 January 2019 concerning 70 bronze monkey sculptures by Jörg Immendorff (report).

The sculptures had been commissioned by a Swiss gallery, St. Gilles. Art dealer Helge Achenbach had been tasked with selling them. When Achenbach became insolvent, his insolvency administrator had the monkeys auctioned by Van Ham in Cologne, raising around €1.66 million for the estate.

The Swiss gallery claimed the proceeds – and won. The administrator had sought to infer ownership from Achenbach’s possession of the works and produced invoices from 2010 and 2011. The court was not persuaded: the figures on those invoices appeared nowhere in Achenbach’s accounts. It concluded that Achenbach had merely stored the sculptures, never owned them.

Doctrinally, this is the territory of § 1006 of the German Civil Code (BGB), which presumes that the possessor of a movable thing is its owner. The presumption is powerful, but it has limits. It only helps someone who possesses the thing as their own. A dealer who holds works on consignment, a warehouse keeper or a borrower holds them for someone else – and an inventory that does not match the books will not fill that gap.

Two jurisdictions, one lesson

Different legal systems, different facts – yet both courts asked the same question and answered it the same way: ownership is proven by documents that match, not by where a work happens to hang.

Bombay High Court (2026)LG Düsseldorf (2019)
Insolvent partyCompany in liquidationArt dealer in insolvency
Works44 paintings, ruling on 570 bronze sculptures
Who claimed against the estateFamily membersSwiss gallery that commissioned the works
Decisive evidenceAsset register, purchase vouchers and seizure records that matchedInvoices that did not appear in the accounts
Outcome5 works fall to the estateProceeds go to the gallery
Mode of saleCourt-appointed art expert oversees the saleAdministrator chose a specialist auction house

The last row marks the real difference. Under German insolvency law, the administrator decides how to realise assets and is liable for doing so poorly; engaging a specialist auction house is a matter of professional diligence, not of a court order. The Düsseldorf administrator did exactly that.

The Mumbai court, by contrast, stepped in itself – both to prescribe a market-appropriate sale and to secure funds for conservation. Such hands-on judicial involvement in the care of an estate’s artworks would be unusual in German proceedings. It shows how seriously the Indian court took the particular nature of art as an asset.

What companies should take from this

For businesses that own art – whether a few pieces in the boardroom or a serious corporate collection – the two cases translate into concrete housekeeping.

1. Inventory with precision. Each work needs an unmistakable description – artist, title, dimensions, medium, year and signature, inventory number, photographs – linked directly to the purchase invoice, proof of payment and provenance documents. The Mumbai liquidator succeeded precisely because register, vouchers and seizure records told the same story.

2. Separate business and private – and document the separation. Works owned by shareholders hanging in company premises, or company-owned art in a managing director’s home, are disputes waiting to happen. Loan agreements, consignment contracts and a clear location register should record who owns what and who merely holds it.

3. Treat storage and care as asset protection. Art loses value quickly when stored badly – and in a crisis, nobody may feel responsible for it. Climate-controlled storage, condition reports, adequate insurance and a named person in charge preserve value for the company and, if it comes to that, for its creditors.

4. Plan for the exit. If works ever have to be sold, the route matters. Specialist auction houses or dealers achieve very different results from a general liquidation sale. Building that expectation into internal policies avoids value being lost in the worst possible moment.

Art on the balance sheet is an asset in its own right. It deserves the same legal care as machinery or real estate – and arguably more, because it is unique, easy to move and sensitive to its environment.

How we can help

KDB.legal advises collectors, galleries, auction houses and other art market participants on art law and the German property and contract law questions behind it.


Kontakt

Sprechen Sie uns an

KDB.legal Koch Boës
Rechtsanwälte

Großer Burstah 25
D – 20457 Hamburg

Tel +49 40 307 090 70
Fax +49 40 307 090 717