The St. Petersburg Arbitrazh Court has held Siemens AG and its former Russian subsidiary subsidiarily liable for the debts of OOO (Russian LLC equivalent) “Neftegaz i Energetika”, marking a landmark insolvency judgment amid sanctions and contested restructuring. © unsplash, Sasun Bughdaryan I. Introduction On 21 August 2025, the Arbitrazh Court of Saint Petersburg and Leningrad […]
Category: Arbitration
Is there a successful path for enforcement of an arbitral award in Russia?
In one of our recent articles (see here), we discussed a case in which the Russian commercial court refused to recognise an arbitral award because it was requested by a foreign company from a so-called unfriendly country without a domestic bank account. Enforcement would result in a violation of the provisional public order. Now, the […]
Arbitrators and Counsel face € 7.5 bn fine by Russian Court in case of continuation of arbitration proceedings
On 9 September 2025, the Moscow Arbitration Court published its full decision on the application for an injunction prohibiting any continuation or maintenance of the arbitration proceedings in relation to Wintershall Dea. This will be examined in more detail below. I. Introduction On 9 September 2025, the Moscow Arbitrazh Court published its full decision on […]
Are even domestic arbitration awards not good enough for enforcement in Russia?
In a series of decisions (Court case no. А43-27728/2024) originating at the Arbitrazh Court in Nizhny Novgorod, a domestic Russian award in favour of a Swiss entity was first recognised and then this decision was lifted by the Court of Appeal and the matter referred back to the first instance court, which then refused enforcement […]
Russian Court issues injunction against Claimant, Arbitrators and Counsel in Energy Treaty dispute
Russia acts not only against foreign parties, but also against counsel and arbitrators
On 29 April 2025, the Moscow Arbitrazh Court (Case Number: А40-92702/25-56-674) granted a motion applied for by the General Prosecutor’s Office of the Russian Federation for interim relief, ordering the suspension of all arbitration procedures in the case of Wintershall Dea GmbH v. Russian Federation. The order applies until the court issues a final ruling […]
Even an arbitration clause in favour of a seat in a ‘friendly’ country can be overturned by Russian courts.
Introduction On August 28, 2024, the Arbitrazh Court of Primorsky Kray in Russia issued a notable ruling in Case А51-7534/2024. The dispute involved a Russian plaintiff and an Irish defendant concerning the modification of a bareboat charter agreement for a vessel, as well as the recognition of ownership rights over that vessel. Background facts The […]
Another case of “jurisdictional ping-pong” aka Russian Court Decision denies – again – recognition and enforcement of arbitral award
Mike Ackerman via Unsplash In another case of “jurisdictional ping-pong” (see other cases discussed by us here and here), the Arbitrazh Court of the Sverdlovsk Region rendered a judgment on 16 August 2024 (case no. A60-24839/2024) in a legal dispute between a Polish claimant and a Russian defendant regarding the recognition and enforcement of an […]